Pre-selected Assortments

We’ve put together assortments for those of you too lazy to make your own. Whether it’s for the food snob, cheese rookie, or dedicated Baumgartner’s fan, we have the perfect assortment!

6 Items

per page
Set Descending Direction
  1. Party Box
    Cheese Party
    $94.95

    One pound each of Mild Brick, Baby Swiss, 5 Year Cheddar, Pepper Havarti, 3 Year Swiss, Smoked Blue, Horseradish and Chive Farmer, with one jar of our Horseradish Mustard and a two pound smoked Summer Sausage.***Any pre selcted assortments will be shipped in the same box as any other purchased items.

  2. Great things in small packages
    Great things in a small package
    $19.95

    Our two biggest sellers made easy to order. 1 pound each of our Mild Brick and our 5 Year Cheddar; giving you the best of both worlds, mild and sharp.

  3. Milds and Milds of Cheeses
    Milds and Milds of Cheeses
    $27.00

    1 pound each of Mild Brick, Mild Swiss, Mild Cheddar, and Creme Havarti. Just real, simple, good cheese.

  4. Not Just Cheese
    Not "Just" Cheese
    $34.00

    One pound each of the Cranberry Cheddar, Pepper Havarti, Horseradish and Chive Farmer, and one half pound of the Garlic Brun-uusto.

  5. Our Favorites
    Our Favorite Cheeses
    $36.00

    One pound each of the Mild Brick, Baby Swiss, 5 Year Cheddar, and Pepper Havarti (Jalepeno peppers that is). These are our three best sellers, with one we think should be.

  6. Sensory Overload
    Sensory Overload Cheeses
    $60.00

    One pound each of Limburger, Gruyere, Stilton, and 5 Year Cheddar. These cheeses are all very flavorful and/or very smelly. As with all cheese you'll get the most out of these at room temperature.

6 Items

per page
Set Descending Direction

Best Sellers