Hours

Sunday - Thursday 8:00AM - 11:00PM

Friday & Saturday 8:00AM - Midnight

Contact Us

1023 16th Ave

Monroe, WI

E  /  baumgartnercheesestore@gmail.com

​T  /  (608) 325-6157

  • Facebook

Cheese Sandwiches

Our cheese sandwich selection hasn't changed much since 1931. We serve a thick slice of cheese on dark rye bread. You can choose from the classics: swiss, brick, cheddar, and limburger or any of the other cheese we sell in our store. Add fresh salami or braunschweiger to make it a combination. We recommend adding a slice of crisp red onion for extra flavor and crunch. All of our sandwiches are served with our house-recipe horseradish mustard, a sweet hot mustard, and horseradish mayo. 

Hot Sandwiches

In addition to our cheese sandwiches, we have a rich selection of hot, deli-style sandwiches. We serve these on a hearty, light rye bread with a crisp pickle and slab of brick cheese. Add the melted cheese of your choice for a sandwich that is sure to entice the tastebuds! We also offer locally made smoked bratwurst,  hot dogs, and chili dogs. Just like our cheese sandwiches, these are served with our house-recipe horseradish mustard, a sweet hot mustard, and horseradish mayo. You're sure to find a sandwich your will enjoy to the last bite!

Sides

We have several sides available to complete your meal. Our home-made chili is by far the most popular! We call it the "second-best" chili since no one makes chili better than mom. Top it with cheese, onions, or sour cream for a delicious addition to your meal. We also offer a rotating selection of hearty soups in addition to fresh coleslaw, potato salad, and chips. Don't forget to add a cheese plate to your order for the table to share!